Triggers: The Good, the Bad and the Helpful

Become a Trigger Sleuth

When living with a dog, it is important to understand triggers — what they are, how they affect our dogs and why our dogs respond to them the way they do.

A trigger is something that causes an emotional response. It might be something your dog sees, hears or smells. It could be a place, an object, a person, another animal — or even a sequence of events that predicts what is about to happen next.

And triggers aren’t necessarily bad. Some predict scary things. Others predict wonderful things.

Understanding both gives us another way to support our dogs.

Safety comes first

Research has shown that humans and dogs share many of the same basic brain structures. There is a relationship between brain and body size, so it is no surprise that a dog’s brain is considerably smaller than ours. However, many of the fundamental structures are remarkably similar.

Like us, dogs have a cerebral cortex and cerebellum, as well as subcortical structures including the brainstem, hippocampus, amygdala and basal ganglia. These different regions play important roles in functions such as movement, memory, learning and emotion.¹

¹ Gregory Berns, Decoding the Canine Mind, Professor of Neuroeconomics at Emory University, 2020.

Human and non-human animals need to feel safe for the thinking parts of the brain to work effectively. And that safety isn’t only physical — emotional safety matters too.

When we’re faced with something our brain associates with danger, our nervous system can shift away from thoughtful decision-making and towards survival.

Do we need to flee?

Do we need to fight?

Do we need to freeze?

This isn’t a conscious decision. The body is preparing us to deal with a perceived threat.

Our dogs have their own versions of this experience.

Let me give you a human example

I’m terrified of heights — particularly heights where I need to travel upwards, such as escalators or steep, winding staircases without solid barriers to cling to.

Rationally, I know I’m unlikely to fall.

My emotional brain has other ideas.

My heart starts beating faster.
My breathing becomes shallow.
My vision narrows.
My palms start sweating.
I stop properly hearing what’s happening around me.

Then I reach the safety of another solid level. Almost immediately, those symptoms begin to disappear and I can think clearly again.

Sound familiar?

Someone telling me, “Don’t be silly, you’re perfectly safe,” isn’t going to change what my nervous system is doing in that moment.

And this is important when we think about our dogs.

What are your dog’s triggers?

Think about your own dog.

Can you identify things that create a negative emotional response?

It might be a sound.
A smell.
Something they see.
A particular environment.
Another dog.
A person.
An object.

Their response may also change depending on the intensity of the trigger or their distance from it.

A dog who feels threatened by another dog might bark and lunge in an attempt to make that threat go away.

Another might make their body very small, avoid eye contact and try to increase distance.

Some dogs become frantic and appear to “lose their head”.

Others become over-excited — snatching food, spinning, jumping or barking.

These behaviours are information.

Rather than asking, “How do I stop this behaviour?”, we can ask:

What is my dog telling me about their experience right now?

Coping isn’t the same as feeling safe

As guardians, one of our responsibilities is learning to notice changes in our dogs.

Is my dog genuinely comfortable?

Are they beginning to struggle?

Are they coping?

Are they approaching their threshold?

Have they already gone beyond it?

The earlier we notice those changes, the more opportunities we have to change the environment, increase distance, offer choice or simply get our dog out of a situation they are no longer comfortable in.

Because learning becomes very difficult when the nervous system is concerned with survival.

If we listen to what our dogs are telling us, we can support them with patience, thoughtful management and gentle guidance.

Control the environment, not the dog.

But triggers can be wonderful too

Here’s where triggers become really interesting.

Our dogs’ lives are also filled with positive triggers.

In fact, you’ve probably created dozens without even realising it.

Have you ever been working on your laptop while your dog snoozes peacefully nearby?

You close the laptop lid. Suddenly your dog is standing beside you, ready for their afternoon walk.

How did they know?

Or consider one of the most internationally recognised dog triggers:

the fridge door.

Your dog could be asleep at the opposite end of the house, but somehow the moment that fridge opens…

“Did someone say cheese?”

Our dogs are brilliant detectives.

They notice tiny patterns and learn what predicts what. Keys might predict a car ride. Walking shoes might predict an adventure. A particular training bag might predict Nosework.

A crate appearing might predict relaxation — or it might predict something very different, depending on the dog’s learning history.

The trigger itself isn’t necessarily positive or negative.

It’s what the dog has learned it predicts that matters.

Become a Trigger Sleuth

For the next week, I’d like to invite you to become a detective yourself.

Don’t try to change anything yet.

Just watch.

What happens when you pick up your car keys?

What happens when the crate comes out?

What happens when someone knocks on the door?

What happens when you put your walking shoes on?

What happens when you reach for the lead?

What happens when you pick up a particular toy?

Look beyond the obvious behaviour, too.

Watch your dog’s body.

What happens to their ears, eyes, mouth and tail?

Does their body become softer or tighter?

Do they move towards something or away from it?

Does their movement become faster?

Can they still sniff, explore, eat and respond to you?

Behaviour is information.

Understanding emotional states

The illustration above shows eight emotional states your dog may move through.

  • Afraid: Your dog is in survival mode. Learning isn’t the priority here – safety is.
  • Anxious: Your dog isn’t comfortable and may quickly move towards fear if the situation becomes more difficult.
  • Not Fun: Life isn’t much fun right now. Your dog isn’t in an optimal state for learning or engagement and may move towards anxiety — or, with the right support and environment, towards comfort.
  • Comfortable: Your dog feels safe and relaxed. Their needs are being met and they can rest and engage with their environment.
  • Interested: Your dog is curious and engaged with what’s happening around them.
  • Excited: Your dog is actively engaged and ready to learn. You’re working together and having fun.
  • Over-excited: Excitement is becoming harder to regulate. Your dog may be approaching the edge of what they can comfortably manage.
  • Over-threshold: Your dog has tipped beyond a level of arousal they can cope with. They may no longer hear you, notice things around them or respond to familiar cues. Just like when they are afraid, learning is no longer possible in this state. They need our help to return to a state where they can cope again.These states aren’t rigid boxes, and dogs can move between them quickly.

Our job isn’t to force them into a different emotional state.

Instead, we can change the conditions around them so their nervous system has the opportunity to move towards safety, comfort and engagement.

Sometimes that means training.

Sometimes it means changing the environment.

And sometimes the best training decision is simply more distance.

We can create positive triggers

Once we understand how powerful learned associations are, we can use them thoughtfully.

We can borrow positive triggers our dogs already have, and we can deliberately create new ones.

A particular mat can begin to predict relaxation.

A training bag can predict a game.

A phrase can predict an adventure.

An object can signal that something familiar, safe and enjoyable is about to happen.

Over time, that little signal can become powerful because of everything that consistently follows it.

Positive triggers can also become incredibly useful in training.

Rather than always telling our dogs what to do, we can create predictable patterns that help them understand what is about to happen.

Predictability can create confidence.

And confidence creates opportunities for learning.

I’ve put together a downloadable guide to help you start creating positive triggers intentionally with your own dog.

Download: Creating Positive Triggers

Inside, I’ll walk you through how to choose a trigger, build its meaning and use it thoughtfully in everyday life and training.

Because sometimes a tiny signal can become the beginning of something wonderful.

error: Content is protected !!
Scroll to Top